Last week I wrote a blog post about the issue of using bribes to entice kids to do well of high-stakes standardized tests, such as the Maryland graduation required test, the PARCC. Here is Peggy Robertson’s blog post which gives even more insight into why this kind of systematized bribing is such a harmful and degrading practice, not only for students, but administrators, teachers, and public education as a whole.
|Retweet to @aurorak12 please re: PARCC incentives at JewellElementary|
If you read my post from last Sunday you will know that there is currently a PARCC incentive plan afoot in my former school, Jewell Elementary in the Aurora Public School District. The plan will reward students who show great effort on PARCC and who attend on all testing days. It will punish children who do not show great effort. It will punish students whose parents have opted them out.
As you can imagine, the children who don’t show great effort will be the children who are struggling in some shape or form, whether it be due to problems at home, stresses at school, lack of food, fatigue, emotional and behavioral needs that are not addressed, the list goes on. So, our neediest children who test will be punished for lack of effort. The opt out students will be punished because their parents are refusing to allow their children to participate.
This week has been a week of attempting to shut this PARCC incentive plan down. You can read more about it in these links:
And Peter Greene did a nice piece about testing bribes here.
Currently there are lots of rumors running around so it’s hard to know how this will be resolved. These PARCC incentives are not in compliance with the House Bill 15-1323 which was passed in 2015. There is some indication that Aurora believes they have skirted the law successfully because the PARCC incentives occur during school hours (HB 15-1323 states you cannot deny opt out students “extracurricular” activities, which apparently is being translated as activities after school). Jewell is planning raffle prizes and a party during school hours.
So, does that mean it’s okay to punish children during school hours only? Not after school?
There are some rumors that Jewell might pull back from such a harsh stance and bend the policy a little. But the PARCC incentives will indeed remain.
This is not okay. Our children are not dogs to be given treats. Our children should not be taught that compliance is the best policy. Our children should not be taught that this test has any value whatsoever to a child’s life. As Stephen Krashen states regarding these tests, “The tests only serve to enrich the oligarchy. There is no evidence that they help students.”
There is plenty of evidence that they harm students.
Senator Holbert and Senator Kerr are looking into this – they both sponsored HB 15-1323. Hopefully we will hear more on this soon.
In the meantime, I would appreciate any help tweeting to @aurorak12 as well as media. You can find me on Twitter @PegwithPen. Feel free to retweet my tweets or simply create your own. We must continue to push back against policies which harm children.
Many many thanks to all of you.
About Peggy Robertson from her blog:
- I am a writer, activist, gardener, stellar organizer, former public school teacher and current chicken herder. I like to cook incessantly and drink a lot of coffee. I write about education and have recently expanded my activist work into other spaces – stay tuned for more.